Welcome to Ye Olde Fish House
At Ye Olde Fish House, we bring the heart of coastal cuisine to Columbus, Indiana. Our story unfolds in a charming, community-centric atmosphere where every dish is crafted with care. Known for our crispy fish sandwiches and tenderloins, we emphasize quality ingredients and friendly service, ensuring that every visit feels like coming home. Our customers rave about our homemade desserts, from gooey pecan pie to innovative cakes like the blueberry flapjack. Whether you're savoring our perfectly fried fish or enjoying the warm ambiance, Ye Olde Fish House is committed to delivering a memorable dining experience that reflects our passion for great food and community connections.
-
2024 17th St, Columbus, IN 47201, United States Hotline: +1 812-378-2921
Welcome to Ye Olde Fish House, a culinary gem located at 2024 17th St, Columbus, IN 47201. This charming establishment has quickly become a beloved local favorite, and it's easy to see why. With a commitment to serving fresh, flavorful seafood and a warm, inviting atmosphere, Ye Olde Fish House is where great food meets friendly service.
The moment you step inside, you're enveloped in a cozy ambiance that makes you feel right at home. The restaurant often buzzes with the chatter of satisfied diners, yet surprisingly, the line moves promptly—proof of the efficient operation run by the dedicated owner and his attentive staff.
Ye Olde Fish House has earned rave reviews for its delectable offerings. Diners, like Ashley C, have praised the variety on the menu, which includes everything from crispy fish sandwiches to succulent tenderloins, all complemented by sides of fried potatoes, mac and cheese, and green beans. The desserts are not to be missed either, boasting treats like Carrot Cake with Cream Cheese Icing, and intriguing options like Blueberry Flapjack Cake, which left a lasting impression on the taste buds of many patrons.
For those craving authentic southern seafood flavors, Jess Ledesma notes that the fish at Ye Olde Fish House is among the best one can find in central Indiana. The service is equally exceptional, with staff making an effort to connect with customers, remembering their names and previous interactions—a touch that elevates the dining experience.
Roan Dooley highlights the restaurant as a "homely little joint," remarking on the friendly vibe and the must-try fried mushrooms paired with a spicy dipping sauce. The atmosphere is conducive to relaxing and enjoying a hearty meal—a crucial aspect worth considering for diners looking to unwind after a long day.
Another noteworthy point is the generous portion sizes, as mentioned by Kathy Moore, who applauded the ample servings of fish and tenderloins, catering perfectly to families and groups of friends. The attentive staff ensure that every customer feels valued, providing excellent assistance even in more challenging circumstances, such as accommodating those with disabilities.
In conclusion, Ye Olde Fish House stands out not just for its flavorful dishes and welcoming staff, but as a heartfelt reminder of what dining local is all about. With patrons confidently recommending it as a go-to spot for fish sandwiches and comfort food, you owe it to yourself to experience the charms of this delightful establishment.
Plan your visit today, and don’t forget to try their delicious sweet tea!
For reservations or to place a takeout order, call +1 812-378-2921.
Everything was perfect! I had a group of four others with me so we were able to get a little of everything (Fish, tenderloin, fried potatoes, mac and cheese, green beans and 3 desserts). The restaurant was packed but don’t let the line scare you as it moves fast! The owner was right there working with his employees and making sure everything is to perfection. Do yourself a favor and do not forget the cakes and pies! We had a snickers cheesecake, strawberry cheesecake, and something I’ve never heard of, but it was absolutely the best cake ever called a blueberry flapjack cake.
People always complain about local places with good food and service disappearing, well make sure that doesn't happen and support Ye Olde Fish House. Our first visit was great, super friendly, hot crispy fish sandwiches, the best fried taters we've had since Grandma got out the cast iron and a gooey slice of pecan pie. We could've easily spent more at a fast food place and not have had half as good a time.
I just love this place. Im from the south and it’s hard to find good seafood in central Indiana. The fish is sooo good!!! And the service is phenomenal. I’m so impressed by the all around great experience you get from this place. Btw, tonight (my second time eating here) I walked in about 15-20 minutes before they closed and they treated me like I was their first and only customer of the day. Even gave me a piece of fish to eat while my order was being cooked.
I love love love this place. It's such a homely little joint and the fish is incredible. I also *highly* recommend you try the fried mushrooms with the spicy dipping sauce as well as the tenderloin, just be prepared to salt and pepper your food. The guy that owns this place is also just an all around amazing dude. He, and his employees, always make a point of remembering their customers' names and past conversations- they're all just really friendly people.
Delicious and ample quantity of fish and tenderloins. Staff was attentive and so helpful with our family member that's in a wheelchair. Can't wait to eat here again.
First time here and it was delicious! Fantastic customer service. The person in front of me got the last piece of fish. So I had to wait for the next batch to come out. I think it took all of 3 minutes and they apologized multiple times. I got the fish sandwich, which was huge. 5 decent size pieces of fish were on it. I would definitely recommend!!!! The sides looked delicious as well.
Worth the wait. Very decent size fish sandwich and super yummy. The place has a nice cozy feeling definitely a small town gem. Highly recommend the fish sandwich with tartar sauce and the fried potatoes and sweet tea.
We came in today, and we loved it. We ordered takeout and got fish sandwich meal deals. Over-all the food was awesome, I do wish it was a tad more salty. (Nothing I can't add myself) the sweet tea was superb. It reminded me of how my mother used to make it. And the coleslaw was so sweet and crunchy. Pb pie and carrot cake are also 10/10 Parking here is tough if busy